Together for Short Lives
Call the Helpline 0808 8088 100

Racial Differences in Parental Responses to Children’s Chronic Pain

Journal title
The Clinical journal of pain
Publication year
El-Behadli, A. F.; Gansert, P.; Logan, D. E.

OBJECTIVE: Parental responses to children’s pain are related to how youth cope with chronic pain. However, little research has explored cultural differences in the four major pain response categories (i.e., protect, minimize, distract, and monitor). This study compared parental responses to children’s pain between minority parents (i.e., Black, Hispanic, Multiracial) and parents of White children. METHODS: Participants included 234 patients, ages 8-17, with chronic pain (73.5% female; age M(SD)=13.91(2.38); 50% White, 15.39% Black, 20.90% Hispanic, 13.68% Multiracial). Patients’ parents completed the Adult Responses to Children’s Symptoms. Parental responses included: protect, monitor, minimize, and distrct. For between-group comparisons, White participants (N=117) were matched on age and gender with Black (N=36), Hispanic (N=49), and Multiracial (N=32) participants. RESULTS: Paired-samples t-tests revealed that protectiveness was higher for parents of Black children (t(48)=-3.84, P<0.001, Black M(SD)=1.93(0.69), White M(SD)=0.94(0.77), Cohen's d=1.09) and parents of Hispanic children (t(71)=-7.10, P<0.001, Hispanic M(SD)=1.65(0.76), White M(SD)=0.94(0.77), Cohen's d=1.52) compared to parents of White children. Additionally, parents of Black children (t(40)=-2.90, P=0.006, Black M(SD)=3.55(0.49), White M(SD)=2.89(0.93), Cohen's d=0.80) and parents of Hispanic children (t(71)=-3.62, P<0.001, Hispanic M(SD)=3.35(0.69), White M(SD)=2.89(0.93), Cohen's d=0.81) were significantly more monitoring of their children than were parents of White children. Parents of Hispanic children were also significantly more minimizing than parents of White children (t(71)=-3.68, P<0.001, Hispanic M(SD)=0.88(0.75), White M(SD)=0.51(0.58), Cohen's d=0.80) No other significant differences were found. DISCUSSION: Results highlight the need to adapt pediatric chronic pain interventions to family culture and context. Further research is needed to understand pediatric chronic pain from a cross-cultural perspective.

Research abstracts